Sequelize Associations: How a Misplaced belongsTo Broke Our Query (and How to Fix It)

Dinesh Rawat
3 min readFeb 24, 2025

Originally published on shorterloop.com.

As developers, we’ve all faced that moment of dread: your code should work, but instead, your logs fill with cryptic SQL errors. Recently, a team ran into a baffling Sequelize issue — a simple update query for a feedback system suddenly demanded a non-existent feedback_item_id field. Let’s dissect what went wrong, why, and how to avoid this trap.

module.exports = function (sequelize, DataTypes) {
const feedbackItem = sequelize.define("idm_feedback_items", {
// ... title, status, etc. ...
status: {
type: DataTypes.STRING,
defaultValue: STATUS.active
},
user_id: DataTypes.INTEGER, // Foreign key for user
category_id: DataTypes.INTEGER, // Foreign key for category
});

feedbackItem.associate = (models) => {
// 🚩 Problematic association!
feedbackItem.belongsTo(models.idm_ideas_tags, {
foreignKey: "feedback_item_id",
as: "taggings"
});

// Correct many-to-many setup with tags
feedbackItem.belongsToMany(models.tags, {
through: models.idm_ideas_tags,
foreignKey: "feedback_item_id",
as: "tags"
});
};

return feedbackItem;
};

Everything seemed fine — until they ran an update:

await feedback_items.update(
{ status: "deleted" },
{ where: { external_key: "IDEA-10", product_id: 1131 } }
);

Suddenly, their logs showed:

SELECT ..., `feedback_item_id` FROM `idm_feedback_items` WHERE ...;

The problem? The feedback_item_id column didn’t exist in their table. Why did Sequelize include it?

The Culprit: Misusing belongsTo

The root cause was an incorrect association. Let’s break it down:

1. The Offending Code

In the associate function:

feedbackItem.belongsTo(models.idm_ideas_tags, {
foreignKey: "feedback_item_id", // 🚩 Red flag!
as: "taggings"
});

2. Why This Broke

  • idm_ideas_tags was a junction table for a many-to-many relationship between feedback items and tags.
  • Using belongsTo incorrectly implied that idm_feedback_items had a direct foreign key feedback_item_id pointing to the junction table.
  • Sequelize assumed feedback_item_id was a column in idm_feedback_items and included it in queries.

The Fix: Use belongsToMany for Junction Tables

Step 1: Remove the Incorrect Association

Delete the problematic belongsTo block:

// Remove this entirely!
// feedbackItem.belongsTo(models.idm_ideas_tags, { ... });

Step 2: Strengthen the Many-to-Many Setup

Ensure the relationship uses belongsToMany:

feedbackItem.belongsToMany(models.tags, {
through: models.idm_ideas_tags, // Junction table
foreignKey: "feedback_item_id", // Field in JUNCTION table
otherKey: "tag_id", // Field in JUNCTION table
as: "tags"
});

How This Works:

  • belongsToMany tells Sequelize the relationship is managed via a junction table.
  • foreignKey and otherKey refer to columns in the junction table, not the main model.

Lessons Learned

1. belongsTo vs. belongsToMany

AssociationUse CaseForeign Key LocationbelongsToMany-to-One or One-to-OneCurrent model’s tablebelongsToManyMany-to-Many (via junction)Junction table

2. Common Pitfalls

  • Assuming junction tables need direct associations: They don’t — use belongsToMany.
  • Naming conflicts: Ensure foreign keys in associations don’t clash with existing columns.

3. Debugging Tips

  • Log Sequelize queries: Enable logging: console.log to spot unexpected fields.
  • Validate associations: Double-check foreignKey and through settings.

Best Practices for Sequelize Associations

  1. Map Relationships Early: Sketch your schema to identify junction tables and relationship types.
  2. Use Consistent Naming: Stick to conventions (e.g., feedback_item_id, not feedbackItemId).
  3. Test Associations:
it("should load tags via junction table", async () => {
const feedback = await FeedbackItem.findByPk(1, { include: "tags" });
expect(feedback.tags).to.be.an("array");
});

Final Thoughts

Sequelize associations are powerful but require precision. Misusing belongsTo instead of belongsToMany is a common pitfall with junction tables. By understanding how these methods map to your schema, you’ll avoid unexpected SQL chaos.

Next time your query includes a mysterious field, check your associations — it might save hours of debugging!

Gotchas to Watch For:

  • Accidental belongsTo on junction tables.
  • Typos in foreign key names.
  • Forgetting to define both sides of an association.

Further Reading:

Engage: Ever battled unexpected fields in Sequelize? Share your war stories below! 💬

This article was originally published on shorterloop.com.

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Dinesh Rawat
Dinesh Rawat

Written by Dinesh Rawat

Seasoned software engineer, Content creator, Helping teams achieve their goals. https://www.linkedin.com/in/dinesh-rawat/

No responses yet

Write a response

Recommended from Medium

Lists

See more recommendations